Forgiveness Myths: What the Bible Really Says – Pillar Page

A Silo Pillar Page — Experiencinghisvictory.com

Forgiveness Myths: What the Bible Really Says

Twenty-four of the most common lies about forgiveness — myths that keep believers in bondage — examined and answered with Scripture. All 24 posts in sequence.

“Bearing with one another, and forgiving each other, whoever has a complaint against anyone; just as the Lord forgave you, so also should you.” — Colossians 3:13

Most Christians know they are supposed to forgive. Far fewer actually do it — and the gap is almost always explained by a myth. Some believe forgiveness requires forgetting. Others think it makes them a doormat, or that it lets the offender off the hook, or that they simply cannot forgive someone who has hurt them deeply. These myths feel true. They sound reasonable. And they keep millions of believers in the bondage of bitterness that Jesus died to free them from. This twenty-four-post series takes on the most persistent forgiveness myths one by one — examining exactly what the Bible says about each one. This is a companion to the forgiveness content in the Invisible Barriers series, providing deeper examination of individual myths for those working through specific forgiveness obstacles.



If you would like to receive these posts by email, click here.

MYTHS
1–24

Forgiveness Myths: The Complete Series

24 posts  •  What Forgiveness Is and Is Not

Forgiveness is one of the most misunderstood topics in the Christian life. The myths surrounding it are not trivial misunderstandings — they are lies that lock people into ongoing bitterness, relational destruction, and spiritual torment. The enemy has a strong interest in keeping believers from forgiving, because unforgiveness is one of the most effective invisible barriers to spiritual growth and freedom. Each post in this series takes on a single myth — names it, examines why people believe it, and then shows precisely what Scripture says instead. Whether you are wrestling with a specific myth yourself or helping someone else work through forgiveness, these posts provide the clear, biblical truth needed to set the captive free.
Myth 1
Forgiveness Is Not Easy

Many assume forgiveness is simple — just “forgive and forget.” But as Terry shows through the story of Corrie Ten Boom, forgiveness is one of the hardest things we will ever do. It is not natural. It takes real effort, especially when the offense seems unforgivable. But God never asks us to do something He won’t empower us to do — and when forgiveness seems impossible, it becomes an invitation to trust Him.

Myth 2
Forgiving Gets Easier Over Time

The idea that forgiveness gets easier every time is simply not true. Jesus commanded unlimited forgiveness — “seventy times seven” — not because it becomes more natural, but because it is essential. Being a forgiving person doesn’t mean allowing harmful behavior — it means maintaining a heart free from bitterness while holding wise boundaries. With God’s help, forgiveness is always possible and always worth choosing.

Myth 3
Forgiveness Comes With Time

“Give it time” may be the most common — and most damaging — advice given to those who have been deeply hurt. Time doesn’t heal wounds; it only buries them deeper. Terry shares the story of an 80-year-old woman who carried unhealed trauma for over 60 years. Only when she chose forgiveness was she finally freed. Don’t wait another five years. Bring it to Jesus today.

Myth 4
Some Things Are Too Big to Forgive

Some offenses feel so devastating that forgiveness seems impossible — even insulting. But God’s standard isn’t human fairness — it’s the cross. Jesus died for every sin ever committed. There is no sin too large for His blood to cover. When you release someone who caused you great harm, you’re not saying what they did was acceptable. You’re saying, “God, I trust You with this.”

Myth 5
Once You Forgive, That’s the End of It

Many believe forgiveness is a one-time event — forgive once and it’s done forever. But that’s rarely how it works. Sometimes we must release a person again and again as new reminders surface. This doesn’t mean the original forgiveness failed — it means forgiveness is a lifestyle, not a single event. Keep releasing. Keep walking in the freedom God has for you.

Myth 6
Forgiveness Is About the Other Person

When most people think about forgiveness, their attention goes straight to the offender: “Did they really mean it? Are they truly sorry?” But this misses the truth entirely. Forgiveness isn’t about the other person — it is an issue of your own heart. Ultimately, forgiveness is between you and God. Don’t wait for the offender to come to you. Release them today — not for their sake, but for yours.

Myth 7
Forgiveness Means Reconciling With the Other Person

One of the most common misconceptions about forgiveness is that it automatically restores the relationship. It doesn’t. Forgiveness and reconciliation are two entirely separate things. Forgiveness is an internal act — you release someone on your own. Reconciliation requires two people, acknowledgment of wrong, and genuine repentance. You can forgive completely and still choose not to resume a relationship. Release the person. Trust God with whatever comes next.

Myth 8
Forgiveness Means Ignoring What Happened

Forgiveness is not pretending nothing happened. Real forgiveness takes the opposite approach — it requires honestly acknowledging that you were genuinely wronged. True forgiveness follows clear steps: acknowledge the wrong, choose to forgive, give the pain to God, release the person from your anger, and refuse to weaponize the offense in the future. Forgiveness isn’t ignorance — it is the courageous decision to face the truth and then release it.

Myth 9
Forgiveness Must Be Earned or Deserved

Can we earn God’s forgiveness? Of course not. Forgiveness is a free gift rooted in God’s grace — undeserved favor by definition. So why do we insist that others must earn our forgiveness? Performance-based forgiveness creates control and resentment. When you release the requirement that the offender must earn it, you are released from them. Unforgiveness is the chain. Grace is the key.

Myth 10
Forgiveness Is Free

Forgiveness is free in one sense — it is a gift none of us could earn. But it cost Jesus everything: His friends, His safety, His dignity, and at the cross, His union with the Father. When forgiving someone feels impossible, remember what it cost Him. Jesus, who paid all of that, still prayed, “Father, forgive them.” Because He paid so completely, forgiveness is now available to you.

Myth 11
Forgiveness Is Weakness

Many believe forgiveness is for the weak — that forgiving means the offender won and you lost. But the strongest person who ever lived was a forgiving person. Even as nails pierced His hands, Jesus said, “Father, forgive them.” That is not weakness — it is breathtaking strength. What passes for strength in the world — striking back, holding grudges — is the path of least resistance. Anyone can react. It takes real power to choose release.

Myth 12
Forgiveness Means Downplaying What Happened

One of the most subtle ways people avoid true forgiveness is by minimizing what happened. “She had a hard life.” “He didn’t mean it.” But making excuses isn’t forgiveness — it’s avoidance. True forgiveness looks honestly at what was done and chooses to release the person despite the full weight of their actions. You cannot forgive a “small thing” when the wound is actually a “big thing.” Name the truth. Then forgive it.

Myth 13
Forgiving Is Forgetting

One of the most widespread forgiveness myths is that you must forget what happened in order to have truly forgiven. But the Bible never says forgive and forget — that phrase doesn’t exist in Scripture. This post examines what forgiveness actually does to memory and why forgetting is not the goal or the test of genuine forgiveness.

Myth 14
Forgiveness Can Only Happen if They Ask

Many believe forgiveness is only possible — or only required — when the offender asks for it. But Jesus forgave from the cross before anyone asked. This post examines why this myth keeps believers in perpetual bondage to other people’s choices and what the Bible actually teaches about unconditional forgiveness.

Myth 15
Forgiving Makes Me a Doormat

The fear that forgiveness equals weakness, passivity, or vulnerability to further harm keeps many from releasing offenders. This post examines why this fear is understandable but mistaken — showing that biblical forgiveness is an act of strength, not weakness, and that it does not require continued exposure to harmful behavior.

Myth 16
Forgiveness Removes the Consequences

Some refuse to forgive because they believe it means pretending the offense didn’t happen or nullifying its consequences. This post clarifies what forgiveness does and does not do — showing that forgiving someone does not remove accountability, prevent appropriate consequences, or require acting as if nothing happened.

Myth 17
I Have to Tell the Other Person

Does forgiveness require a face-to-face conversation with the one who hurt you? This post addresses one of the most practically confusing myths about forgiveness — examining when telling someone you forgave them is helpful and appropriate, and when it is unnecessary, unwise, or even potentially harmful.

Myth 18
I Can’t Forgive Because They Are Dead

Death doesn’t close the door on forgiveness. The wound from a parent, sibling, or other person who has died can be just as raw and real as any living offense. This post shows that forgiveness is primarily something that happens between you and God — and explains how to genuinely release the offense of someone who is no longer alive.

Myth 19
I Must Get Over My Hurt First

Waiting until the pain fades before forgiving sounds reasonable — but it has things backwards. The pain rarely fades on its own, and forgiveness is actually the pathway through which healing comes. This post explains why you don’t need to feel better first to forgive, and why extending forgiveness while still hurting is both possible and powerful.

Myth 20
Forgiveness Will Instantly Heal My Heart

On the other end of the spectrum, some expect immediate complete healing the moment they forgive — and when that doesn’t happen, they conclude they haven’t really forgiven. This post clarifies the relationship between forgiveness and healing: forgiveness is a decision; healing is often a process that follows, and both are real.

Myth 21
I’ll Be Disloyal to Those Who Were Hurt

When someone has hurt not just you but others you love — a child, a sibling, a friend — forgiving them can feel like betrayal. This post addresses the painful myth that forgiveness dishonors victims, showing why this is false and how genuine forgiveness actually honors everyone involved, including those who were also harmed.

Myth 22
Forgiveness Means Letting Them Off the Hook

Perhaps the most emotionally powerful myth of all: that forgiving someone means they escape justice. This post shows why this is precisely backwards — that genuine forgiveness actually transfers the matter to God, the only truly just Judge, and that holding unforgiveness is the very thing that allows the offender to keep harming you.

Myth 23
I Can’t Forgive

When the wound is deep enough, forgiveness can feel literally impossible. “I can’t forgive” is the most common — and the most costly — forgiveness myth of all. This closing post in the series directly addresses this declaration, showing why it is never true and how God makes genuine forgiveness possible for every wound, no matter how severe.

Myth 24
Forgiveness Isn’t Fair

Life is deeply unfair — and every fiber of your being cries out for justice, rightly so. But fairness has nothing to do with forgiveness. Jesus looked down from the cross — dying for crimes He never committed — and said, “Father, forgive them.” Because we have been forgiven a massive debt by God, we are called to forgive the smaller debts others owe us. It isn’t fair. But it is the way of the Kingdom — and the only path to genuine freedom.

Connected Series — Continue Your Journey

Seven Invisible Barriers

There are invisible spiritual forces that keep believers from walking in the freedom Christ already purchased. The Seven Invisible Barriers series exposes all seven — Generational Curses, Inner Wounds, Ungodly Beliefs, Strongholds, Unforgiveness, Offense, and Doubt. With 61 posts, this is the most comprehensive series on EHV. Most people stuck in repetitive sin, emotional pain, or spiritual stagnation are dealing with one or more of these barriers without realizing it. Each barrier is systematically explained: what it is, how it forms, how to recognize it, and how to remove it through Christ’s authority. Understanding the barriers is not enough — you must know how to dismantle them. This series gives you both the knowledge and the biblical tools to do exactly that, one barrier at a time.


Eight Steps to Victory

The Eight Steps series is the core framework of EHV — a practical, Scripture-based process for moving from spiritual bondage into lasting freedom. The 44 posts cover eight movements: knowing God’s character and authority, receiving revelation about your own condition, taking action through repentance and renunciation, receiving healing for inner wounds, and walking in the spiritual authority God has given every believer. This is not a formula but a biblical journey. Each step builds on the one before it, forming a complete pathway for anyone serious about experiencing genuine deliverance and lasting victory. Whether you are just beginning or have been seeking freedom for years, the Eight Steps framework meets you where you are and gives you a clear, grace-filled path forward.

>